Tax group fights to stop California’s auto-IRA program

Tax group fights to stop California’s auto-IRA program
The Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association recently lost its case against CalSavers, and has appealed the decision
APR 06, 2020

A conservative tax lobbying group is not finished with its legal fight against California’s auto-IRA program.

The Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association on April 1 appealed a district court’s dismissal of the group’s lawsuit against the California Secure Choice Retirement Savings Program. The program, which launched last year, requires businesses to automatically enroll workers into the program, unless those companies already provide workplace retirement accounts.

The district court judge last month ruled that CalSavers is not a plan under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act and is therefore not preempted by that part of the law. That decision followed a previous dismissal, though the plaintiffs were given the chance to amend their complaint.

The state’s deadline for businesses with 100 or more employees to comply is June 30, and it is phasing in that requirement for smaller businesses over time.

The case was filed in 2018 in U.S. District Court in the Eastern District of California.

Last year, the lawsuit caught the attention of the Trump administration, which sided with the plaintiffs. In September, the Justice Department filed a statement of interest with the court, urging the judge to deny the auto-IRA program’s motion to dismiss. The DOJ had similarly argued that the program ran afoul of ERISA, meaning that the state law is inconsistent with federal law.

The state is among many that have either considered or moved forward with public retirement-savings accounts for private-sector workers. The need for savings is evident in California, as nearly 7 million residents do not have access to employer sponsored plans, the state has noted.

“We remain confident in the district court’s two prior rulings strongly in our favor,” CalSavers executive director Katie Selenski said in an email.

Latest News

Mesirow acquires part of flexPATH in second retirement deal of 2026
Mesirow acquires part of flexPATH in second retirement deal of 2026

Chicago-based Mesirow Fiduciary Solutions adds flexPATH's plan-level outsourced fiduciary book, boosting its retirement market reach to $164 billion.

Advisor moves: LPL lands $350M veteran advisor duo in Florida
Advisor moves: LPL lands $350M veteran advisor duo in Florida

Also, Raymond James's employee advisor channel adds breakaways from Wells Fargo and Stifel, while UBS welcomes an ex-Morgan Stanley duo in Indiana.

SEC accuses crypto firm founder of running $425 million Ponzi scheme
SEC accuses crypto firm founder of running $425 million Ponzi scheme

It promised guaranteed principal and 10% monthly returns. The SEC says it invested nothing.

MassMutual Ascend tops $2 billion in RIA annuity sales as advisors warm to income products
MassMutual Ascend tops $2 billion in RIA annuity sales as advisors warm to income products

Ten years after entering the fee-based annuity market, MassMutual Ascend says nearly half its lifetime sales came in the past two years alone – but barriers remain among fee-only advisors.

Fintech bytes: Wealth tech firms target advisor productivity with new integrations
Fintech bytes: Wealth tech firms target advisor productivity with new integrations

Amplify, WealthReach, Zeplyn and Zocks have unveiled partnerships aimed at automating portfolio management, content creation, account opening, and client communication.

SPONSORED Direct indexing webinar targets tax-loss harvesting amid market swings

Northern Trust’s Ken Lassner shows advisors how to convert volatility into after-tax portfolio gains

SPONSORED Who builds the income when the pension disappears?

Dan Biagini of American Equity says the steady decline of pensions, longer lifespans and a reset in interest rates are rewriting how advisors build retirement income