MIT settles class-action suit that snared Fidelity's Abigail Johnson

MIT settles class-action suit that snared Fidelity's Abigail Johnson
Pending settlement in lawsuit could alter Fidelity's 20-year-old record-keeping arrangement with the university.
SEP 13, 2019
The Massachusetts Institute of Technology has reached a settlement agreement in a class-action lawsuit that alleged a quid pro quo arrangement with Fidelity Investments related to the university's 401(k) program. The agreement comes just days before the trial was slated to begin on Monday. [Recommended video: Retirement advisers can boost business by focusing on participants in these ways] Details of the settlement agreement will be made public within 45 days, according to Jerome Schlichter, the attorney representing the class of more than 20,000 current and retired MIT employees. "The employees and retirees of MIT will not only receive compensation, but the retirement plan will be changed and reformed," Mr. Schlichter said. Fidelity was not named as a party in the lawsuit, but the Boston-based asset management giant did take legal action to prevent Fidelity chairman and chief executive Abigail Johnson from having to testify during the trial. Ms. Johnson, a "life member" of MIT's board of trustees, was linked to the lawsuit through Fidelity's 20-year-old 401(k) plan record-keeping agreement with the university. Also, although MIT's retirement plan menu currently includes just one Fidelity fund, for the five years ended in 2015, the menu of options included every Fidelity mutual fund. A Fidelity spokesman declined to comment for this story. The lawsuit alleged that MIT secured Fidelity's record-keeping services and used its mutual funds against the advice of consultants in exchange for donations from Fidelity to the university. According to the lawsuit, when MIT rejected the idea of conducting competitive bidding in 2015, the dean of the university's Sloan School of Management wrote in an email: "But if we are not switching to Vanguard or TIAA-CREF, I am going to expect something big and good coming to MIT from the Johnson family." Shortly thereafter, Fidelity donated $5 million to MIT, representing the school's largest donation in more than 15 years. Mr. Schlichter also claimed that MIT had received more than $23 million in donations from Fidelity since the record-keeping relationship began. In response to a request for comment, an MIT spokeswoman emailed a link to a statement from university provost Martin Schmidt, which justified the settlement as removing a "distraction" and defended MIT's management of its 401(k) plan. The statement reads in part: "Over the last three years, MIT has vigorously defended the actions of the faculty and staff who have devoted their time and expertise to serve as fiduciaries of the plan. We believe that the evidence at trial would have demonstrated that the Institute carefully and prudently managed the 401(k) plan in a manner consistent with the best interests of plan participants and beneficiaries, drawing on the advice of experts in the field and striving to meet the needs and wishes of the MIT community."

Latest News

RIA dealmaking accelerates as three firms hit AUM milestones
RIA dealmaking accelerates as three firms hit AUM milestones

Wealth Consulting Group, Coastline and Maridea report fresh capital, acquisitions and asset growth as advisor M&A keeps climbing

VastAdvisor closes $1 million SAFE round from advisor-side backers
VastAdvisor closes $1 million SAFE round from advisor-side backers

Carson Group's Dani Fava, Jason Pereira of Woodgate Financial, and Sally George of Convergency Partners led the raise as the growth-tech startup builds out its AI platform and leadership bench.

Wells Fargo adds three advisor practices as recruiting rebound continues
Wells Fargo adds three advisor practices as recruiting rebound continues

New teams from William Blair, Ameriprise and UBS bring more than $560 million in combined client assets to the firm's employee and independent channels.

UBS will pay advisors 'handsomely' for banking starting next year
UBS will pay advisors 'handsomely' for banking starting next year

Regulators this year approved UBS Bank USA’s conversion to a nationally chartered bank.

SEC accuses Tricolor executives of hiding $800 million collateral hole
SEC accuses Tricolor executives of hiding $800 million collateral hole

How a subprime lender’s car-loan bonds allegedly unraveled before bankruptcy.

SPONSORED Direct indexing webinar targets tax-loss harvesting amid market swings

Northern Trust’s Ken Lassner shows advisors how to convert volatility into after-tax portfolio gains

SPONSORED Who builds the income when the pension disappears?

Dan Biagini of American Equity says the steady decline of pensions, longer lifespans and a reset in interest rates are rewriting how advisors build retirement income