Amid ESG backlash, responsible investors are holding on to their commitments

Amid ESG backlash, responsible investors are holding on to their commitments
While one-fifth of asset managers have dropped the ESG label, more than half still believe the data has value in mitigating risks and boosting returns.
OCT 24, 2024

New research from Cerulli Associates reveals that despite increasing political pressures, many institutional investors and asset managers in the US remain committed to responsible investing, though some are adjusting their approach to avoid political scrutiny.

The study, US Responsible Investing 2024, highlights how political backlash against environmental, social, and governance considerations has influenced industry behavior.

The report shows that while some institutional investors are reconsidering their stance on ESG, most are standing firm. About one in 10 asset owners have scaled back their integration of ESG factors due to the heated political climate. One-third of institutions (34 percent) were motivated by concerns about the cost and time involved in responding to political pushback, while others acted out of fear of litigation (24 percent) and stakeholder pressure (14 percent).

In contrast, asset managers remain largely undeterred. Not one of those surveyed indicated they were giving up on responsible investing altogether, although 42 percent expressed caution about how they communicate their ESG-related activities, and another 4 percent said they would no longer offer specific responsible investment products.

Michele Giuditta, director at Cerulli, acknowledged that political opposition is influencing some decisions, but the data doesn't support the idea of any fundamental weakening in large investors' RI commitments.

“Despite headwinds from political opponents, commitment to responsible investing remains solid,” she said in a statement Thursday.

Giuditta said just over a third (35 percent) of asset managers expect the anti-ESG movement to have a moderate impact on their assets under management. Still, many are incorporating ESG factors into their investment strategies, including 81 percent who use the data for risk mitigation, 63 percent who believe it's part of their fiduciary duty, and 54 percent who cite enhanced returns.

Among institutional investors continuing with ESG practices, many are adapting by watching their language; all in all, 20 percent of asset managers and asset owners Cerulli surveyed admitted that they've stopped using the ESG acronym. Rather than using the acronym, 50 percent of those institutional investors now prefer the term “sustainable investing,” while others are going with “responsible investing” (33 percent) or “stewardship” (20 percent).

Looking ahead, Cerulli advises asset managers to emphasize the role of ESG data in managing risk and enhancing value. That will be critical if the industry wants to fight a continuing hesitance to embrace ESG within the retail space: by Cerulli's count, two-thirds of advisors (65 percent) are not engaging in ESG or sustainable investing discussions with clients, including 63 percent who say there's a lack of investor demand and 57 percent saying ESG is seen as a political agenda.

“Investment professionals should elaborate on how they are identifying those organizations with sustainable business practices,” Giuditta emphasized.

Latest News

Can advisors still cut through the noise in digital marketing?
Can advisors still cut through the noise in digital marketing?

With a fifth of RIA firms using AI to create marketing content, one leading voice argues a clear identity and focusing on clients will be crucial to success.

With wealth management market cooking, LPL Financial shares hit new highs
With wealth management market cooking, LPL Financial shares hit new highs

LPL Financial is a bellwether for the broader financial advice marketplace.

Wealth tech Alix raises $20M to expand AI-powered estate settlement platform
Wealth tech Alix raises $20M to expand AI-powered estate settlement platform

The San Francisco-based startup's Series A funding, with support from Schwab and Edward Jones Ventures, will reinforce its role in the coming $124 trillion wealth transfer.

Summit Financial adds four RIAs, nets $1.2B in new assets
Summit Financial adds four RIAs, nets $1.2B in new assets

The quartet of deals across New York, Florida, Ohio, and New Mexico reinforces the fast-growing integrator's leading position in the independent space.

Advisor moves: Raymond James welcomes UBS, Wells Fargo teams in bicoastal moves
Advisor moves: Raymond James welcomes UBS, Wells Fargo teams in bicoastal moves

UBS and Wells Fargo have made their own additions in the Northeast, including a Massachusetts duo defecting from Commonwealth.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.