B-D dukes it out with Finra over closure

Finra is playing hardball with a broker-dealer that recently lost a securities arbitration, according to the chief executive of the small broker-dealer that's battling with the regulator.
AUG 31, 2010
Finra is playing hardball with a broker-dealer that recently lost a securities arbitration, according to the chief executive of the small broker-dealer that's battling with the regulator. According to John Hsu, CEO of Pyramid Financial Corp. of Cupertino, Calif., the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc. informed him Aug. 24 that, as a result of the arbitration loss, Pyramid was in violation of net-capital requirements and was required cease operations. Two days later, Mr. Hsu responded by suing Finra, disputing Finra's declaration that Pyramid did not meet net-capital rules and seeking a temporary restraining order to allow it to stay in business. But on Friday, a federal judge in U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California in San Jose dismissed the petition for a TRO. Pyramid and Mr. Hsu “must exhaust their claims before Finra and the SEC before seeking review in the federal courts,” wrote Judge Lucy H. Koh. A slew of small and independent broker-dealers have ceased operations this year because they ran afoul of Finra's net-capital requirements. That list includes a few fairly well-known firms, including GunnAllen Financial Inc. and Jesup & Lamont Securities Corp. It appears that dozens of other broker-dealers are facing millions of dollars in potential legal claims stemming from investments that crashed during the recession. Some brokerage executives and securities lawyers have become openly fearful that Finra will use the net capital rule — and how B-Ds book losses from arbitration claims — to shutter firms. (To read more about this, click here). “I feel like my personal rights and business rights are not being protected,” said Mr. Hsu, who is also Pyramid Financial's principal owner. Last week, “Finra just walked in and demanded we close our offices.” The firm's profile on Finra's BrokerCheck shows that on Aug. 16, Pyramid Financial lost a $339,000 arbitration award involving common stock and options. According to Ms. Koh's decision, the arbitration award left Pyramid left with insufficient reserves to meet it net-capital requirements. That provision — a Securities and Exchange Commission regulation — requires broker-dealers to maintain a certain amount of net capital at all times. The levels, however, vary widely from firm to firm. And according to a court document, management at Pyramid Financial believed it had a 30-day grace period to raise the money to pay the arbitration award — and therefore believed the firm did not face an immediate shutdown. Mr. Hsu claimed Finra has a negative attitude toward small firms because of a perception that those firms are more likely to have problems with compliance. He added that Pyramid had foreign accounts. Finra, he says, believes that small firms with offshore clients present a higher business risk. Finra has taken other actions against Pyramid, according to BrokerCheck. Last month, Finra rebuked the firm after it found that Pyramid's chief compliance officer had used personal e-mail to conduct firm business. The regulator also cited the firm for failing to conduct identity checks on clients and failing to implement adequate money-laundering policies Mr. Hsu said his lawyer had returned to court today in an effort to get the restraining order. Nancy Condon, a spokeswoman for Finra, declined to comment.

Latest News

Former CFA Institute exec charged with embezzling almost $5M
Former CFA Institute exec charged with embezzling almost $5M

Ex-CMO accused of using the organization’s money to fund a luxury lifestyle.

'Not every RIA needs to sell to a big aggregator'
'Not every RIA needs to sell to a big aggregator'

Altruist founder and CEO Jason Wenk shares insights on the custodial platform's refresh, how it's striking a chord among entrepreneurial advisors, and what's ahead after its latest $152 million funding round.

Northern Trust vows continued independence after BNY report
Northern Trust vows continued independence after BNY report

Following Wall Street Journal reporting from unnamed sources, the Chicago-based financial giant stressed its commitment to "delivering long-term value to our stakeholders."

California advisor who took cash from cannabis client barred
California advisor who took cash from cannabis client barred

The advisor, Andrew Nash of El Capitan Advisors, used the funds to buy a house, according to the SEC.

Robo platform Wealthfront teases IPO plans
Robo platform Wealthfront teases IPO plans

The digital investment platform's announcement of a confidential submission to the SEC comes amid a broader trend of consumer fintech firms going to market.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.

SPONSORED Beyond the dashboard: Making wealth tech human

How intelliflo aims to solve advisors' top tech headaches—without sacrificing the personal touch clients crave