Better-off Americans cut back on spending which could foretell bad news

Better-off Americans cut back on spending which could foretell bad news
Report reveals sharp drop in spending intentions among upper-income earners.
JAN 16, 2025

There are several big questions concerning the US economy including the impact of potential tariffs, what the Fed will do with interest rates, and whether inflation could soar again.

With economic uncertainty comes caution and it seems that better-off Americans are being more careful with their spending while they wait to see a clearer picture of how the economy may fare in 2025 – and how their investment portfolios may perform.

The latest Bain & Company/Dynata Consumer Health Indexes reveal a significant drop in spending intentions among upper-income earners for January following a smaller decrease in December.

Given that investment portfolios are the primary asset for the cohort covered by the index, the decrease of 10.8 points to 96.5 (from 107.3 in December when there was a 3.2-point decline from November) is reflective of the downturn in the S&P 500 seen last month (down 3.5%) following a 28% gain for the equities index in the first eleven months of 2024.

“We think this trend is linked to December’s pull-back in the equity markets hitting these earners’ portfolios, commented Brian Stobie, senior director Bain & Company’s Macro Trends Group.

It’s notable that the broader barometer that the indexes provide – down 2.6 points in January and 3 points in December - does not show such a sharp drop among other income groups.

While the report notes that upper-income earners spending intentions may recover in February, as they did last year following a large January drop, it also notes that the average for the whole of 2024 was below average.

“Given that upper-income earners represent the majority of discretionary spending in the US, and that American consumers play a critical and outsized role in global demand generation, this is a worrying indicator early in 2025,” said Stobie, adding that this could have a negative impact on consumer-facing businesses during the uncertainty of the months ahead.

Latest News

Advisor moves: Veteran teams with $580M in assets leave Wells Fargo
Advisor moves: Veteran teams with $580M in assets leave Wells Fargo

The experienced advisory teams join Ameriprise and Janney as the race for experienced talent continues.

Siebert deepens FusionIQ investment with 10-year wealth tech deal
Siebert deepens FusionIQ investment with 10-year wealth tech deal

Additional investment and partnership will see joint development of wealth management, brokerage and digital asset platforms.

Medicare Advantage members hit hard by rising costs
Medicare Advantage members hit hard by rising costs

Rising drug and outpatient costs are pushing plan members to demand more financial guidance and most insurers are falling short.

FINRA eyes fraud 'speed bump' rule doubling hold to 10 business days
FINRA eyes fraud 'speed bump' rule doubling hold to 10 business days

FINRA's proposed rule filing would create a new 10-day fraud delay and nearly triple the maximum hold period for exploited senior investors.

MAI Capital pushes into Atlanta with Waypoint Wealth deal
MAI Capital pushes into Atlanta with Waypoint Wealth deal

Fueled by a recent shot in the arm from private equity firm Carlyle, MAI adds a $490 million Atlanta RIA as it keeps building out its national footprint.

SPONSORED Direct indexing webinar targets tax-loss harvesting amid market swings

Northern Trust’s Ken Lassner shows advisors how to convert volatility into after-tax portfolio gains

SPONSORED Who builds the income when the pension disappears?

Dan Biagini of American Equity says the steady decline of pensions, longer lifespans and a reset in interest rates are rewriting how advisors build retirement income