Buy-and-hold is bunk, says Wealth Builders' Schreiber

Buy-and-hold is bunk, says Wealth Builders' Schreiber
The portfolio manager says investors get squeamish when the during market drops, and often sell at big losses.
MAR 02, 2011
When markets are choppy, investors should choose cash over the staid concept of buy-and-hold, according to Donald Schreiber, co-portfolio manager and chief executive of Wealth Builders Inc., which has $625 million under management. “The idea of buy-and-hold, regardless of market cycles, is the most ridiculous thing I've ever heard,” he said. “We know when markets go down, investors will often panic and sell at a loss, so we know buy-and-hold doesn't work — and that's why we should stop telling people to do it.” The WBI Absolute Return Balanced Fund (WBADX), which Mr. Schreiber helps manage, currently has a 25% allocation to cash, reflecting the rising risk in the fixed-income market. The fund, which was launched in December to give retail investors access to a strategy that has been managed as a separate account for 19 years, has the flexibility to hold 100% cash. “We're more than happy to hold cash if we need to,” Mr. Schreiber said. The portfolio, which is designed for a target balance of 50% stocks and 50% bonds, is currently playing defense against the looming threat of inflation and rising interest rates. On the equity side, there is a 54% allocation to dividend-paying stocks. But the fixed-income component of the strategy has been trimmed to just 21% of the portfolio, and durations have been shortened to protect the fund from being caught flat-footed if the bond market starts to adjust to inflation. “You want dynamic risk management, both on the bond and the equity side of a portfolio,” he said. While Mr. Schreiber has trimmed the bond exposure, he continues to enjoy solid income from corporate dividend payouts, which have been rising over the past decade at more than double the rate of inflation. Over 10 years through the end of 2010, the average annualized dividend payout of the 30 companies making up the Dow Jones Industrial Average grew by 6%. Inflation over the same period, as measured by the consumer price index, grew by 2.4% annually. “The rate of increase [in dividend payouts] is really exciting, because investors are looking for ways to keep pace with inflation,” he said. “You can't keep pace with inflation by just holding bonds.” In managing the equity portion of the fund, Mr. Schreiber applies a quantitative value bias that concentrates on income statements, balance sheets and overall growth trends. Ideally, any stock added to the portfolio should have a dividend yield of at least 50 basis points more than that of the S&P 500 Index, which is currently yielding 1.8%. The total income component of the fund, which includes stock dividends and interest from bonds, averages around 4% annually. Even though Mr. Schreiber is currently less bullish on bonds, he will remain nimble on the category by shortening or extending the duration of the individual bonds in the fund as the market environment evolves. “This is a strategy designed for conservative investors,” he said. “The goal is to capture the up market returns when the price trends are positive, but when the price trends turn negative, we shift from return mode to capital protection mode.” Portfolio Manager Perspectives are regular interviews with some of the most respected and influential fund managers in the investment industry. For more information, please visit InvestmentNews.com/pmperspectives.

Latest News

Modera, Simplicity announce new acquisitions in busy day for industry M&A
Modera, Simplicity announce new acquisitions in busy day for industry M&A

Two RIAs expand their geographic footprints with deals in New York's Capital Region and coastal Alabama.

Advisor moves: Ameriprise, Prospera, Raymond James land teams with $920M in assets
Advisor moves: Ameriprise, Prospera, Raymond James land teams with $920M in assets

A 27-year Merrill veteran, Florida advisors, and a trio of New Jersey advisors just moved to new platforms.

LPL Research launches 17 model portfolios, hitting $100B in AUM
LPL Research launches 17 model portfolios, hitting $100B in AUM

Broker-dealer expands its model portfolio platform with modular building block strategies designed to give advisors greater customization at scale.

Wealth Enhancement adds $592M Chicago-area RIA
Wealth Enhancement adds $592M Chicago-area RIA

The mega-RIA with roughly $160 billion in client assets remains firmly in acquisition mode amid rumors of private equity giants vying to scoop it up.

Annuity sales hit a record as war and Fed jitters redraw fixed income
Annuity sales hit a record as war and Fed jitters redraw fixed income

Record annuity demand for principal protection collides with the most hawkish Fed dissent since 2016.

SPONSORED Direct indexing webinar targets tax-loss harvesting amid market swings

Northern Trust’s Ken Lassner shows advisors how to convert volatility into after-tax portfolio gains

SPONSORED Who builds the income when the pension disappears?

Dan Biagini of American Equity says the steady decline of pensions, longer lifespans and a reset in interest rates are rewriting how advisors build retirement income