Fidelity forced to play defense against Schwab's custody pledge

Fidelity forced to play defense against Schwab's custody pledge
Custodian gets called out at the worst possible moment for imposing fees on RIAs that don't use its cash sweep accounts
FEB 14, 2020

A social media buzz Thursday over new custody fees at Fidelity Investments put the Boston-based giant on the defensive in the wake of a pledge from rival Charles Schwab Corp. to move seemingly in the opposite direction.

As Schwab was touting a promise to roll out the red carpet, with no custody fee attached, for smaller registered investment advisers, tweets from social media maven Michael Kitces were triggering chatter about Fidelity layering on new custody fees for RIAs that aren’t sweeping client cash onto its in-house platform.

Mr. Kitces, director of wealth management at Pinnacle Advisory Group, didn't mention Fidelity by name in his tweets, but did refer to a "not-Schwab" custodian reaching out to firms that are not profitable to Fidelity.

A Fidelity representative confirmed that conversations related to pricing take place on an ongoing basis.

"Fidelity is not introducing new fees, we have always offered clients a range of options and work with them collaboratively to identify the right pricing for the RIA," said Nicole Abbott, Fidelity spokeswoman.

"We encourage our RIA clients to focus on the total cost of ownership of a custody account," she added. "This includes the yield on cash sweep choices, commissions and other fees."

While the timing of the social media chatter couldn’t have been worse for Fidelity, this is not a new policy.

“Pricing discussions are a normal course of business for us, and we believe they are most meaningful when they are collaborative discussions,” David Canter, head of Fidelity’s RIA segment, said in a statement.

“Fidelity has always taken a relationship-based pricing approach because this helps ensure that we are aligned with the needs of the firms we serve, while also offering choice and the solutions that advisers need to deliver on their fiduciary responsibility,” Mr. Canter continued.

Fidelity’s response is in line with comments made by Mike Durbin, president of Fidelity Institutional, to Wealth Management in November, when he said a “not insignificant minority” of advisers who custody at Fidelity already operate under a fee-based model.

According to a Fidelity representative, the fee models paid by some advisers to custody on the platform can vary and are sometimes requested by the advisers who would rather pay some kind of fee or pass it along to clients than use Fidelity’s cash sweep accounts.

While Mr. Kitces has highlighted and called out the “notable divergence when Fidelity is pushing out more custody fees and defending them as an industry practice while Schwab just unequivocally pledged not to do so,” he also believes the industry will ultimately have to follow the direction of Fidelity.

“I believe that in the long run, the model will be a basis-point custody fee, and that for fee-only RIAs, they should ultimately want a fee-only custodian, which necessitates custody fees,” he said.

Latest News

Chicago’s 'Mr. Finance' posed as advisor in loan scheme, according to Illinois regulators
Chicago’s 'Mr. Finance' posed as advisor in loan scheme, according to Illinois regulators

The Illinois order refers to Brandon Ellington’s investment program as a “Ponzi-like scheme.”

Bezos calls for zero income tax on bottom half of earners
Bezos calls for zero income tax on bottom half of earners

But the Amazon executive chair seems to want it both ways, arguing that taxing the ultra-wealthy won't help struggling Americans.

Why the Charity Parity Act matters for retired clients in 401(k)s
Why the Charity Parity Act matters for retired clients in 401(k)s

Northern Trust planning leader sees the bill extending qualified charitable distributions to employer plans as a potential positive step — but advisors shouldn't overlook bigger holes in the strategy.

Trust is built before volatility arrives
Trust is built before volatility arrives

Markets will always create reasons for investors to worry. The advisor’s role is not to predict uncertainty, but to help clients understand why volatility should not derail a well-built financial plan.

Fintech bytes: Orion and Flourish bring client cash into advisor workflows
Fintech bytes: Orion and Flourish bring client cash into advisor workflows

Plus, Asset-Map partners with Contio to elevate the advisor meeting experience, and MyVest claims an innovation in portfolio management with separately managed models.

SPONSORED Beyond wealth management: Why the future of advice is becoming more human

As technical expertise becomes increasingly commoditized, advisors who can integrate strategy, relationships, and specialized expertise into a cohesive client experience will define the next era of wealth management

SPONSORED Durability over scale: What actually defines a great advisory firm

Growth may get the headlines, but in my experience, longevity is earned through structure, culture, and discipline