Miami advisors fight over book of business

Miami advisors fight over book of business
'Handshake' deal goes wrong for two south Florida advisors.
MAY 23, 2024

It's typical if not expected in the broad financial advice industry for the firm, usually a broker-dealer, to fight with a financial advisor over his or her clients, known as the advisors' book of business, when the advisor bolts to exit and work at another firm or set up shop independently.

But advisors struggle over control of clients, and the fees and commissions those customer accounts generate, too.

In an arbitration dispute that took more than four years to decide, two former business associates and Miami, Fla.-based financial advisors, Eduardo Augsten and Gustavo Vega, were fighting over revenues generated by the "book of business," according to a recent arbitration award.

The root of the dispute was that the two partners were working with only a "handshake" agreement, rather than a written contract, said Jeffrey Sonn, Augsten's attorney.

"They operated the firm under a handshake deal and that was the mistake," Sonn said in an interview on Thursday. "The reason why financial advisors have these agreements is to avoid these kinds of fights."

According to the award from May 17, in which three Finra dispute resolution services arbitrators awarded Augsten $376,000, his complaint stemmed from the "dissolution" of the partners' business, a firm called Wealthengage.

Both were financial advisors in South Florida registered with Raymond James Financial Services Inc. at the time Augsten sued Vega.

Javier Rodriguez, Vega's attorney, declined to comment about the matter.

In the lawsuit, filed in January 2020, Augsten was seeking unspecified compensatory and punitive damages; costs related to the joint office and lease, and other issues, according to the Finra award.

Regarding the book of business, Augsten was seeking an “equitable lien on the revenues" generated by the clients fees and commissions, according to the award, as well as reimbursement for any debts he was charged after the partnership ended.

"Augsten was 50% owner of the firm, and he contributed a lot of money to the company to start it," Sonn said. "Augsten was the back office of the operation while Vega was the front of the house. and they were his clients. But the two had a five-year lease together."

"The arbitration panel agreed with Augsten and we're very happy with the result, but if you're an advisor, make sure you have a clear agreement and not just a handshake," Sonn said, adding that his colleagues Adolfo Anzola  and Brian Pastor also represented Augsten in the case.  

Chuck Failla breaks down his campaign for advisors to go RIA

Latest News

SEC to lose Hester Peirce, deepening a commissioner crisis
SEC to lose Hester Peirce, deepening a commissioner crisis

The "Crypto Mom" departure would leave the SEC commission with just two members and no Democratic commissioners on the panel.

Florida B-D, RIA owner pitches bold long-term plan to sell to advisors
Florida B-D, RIA owner pitches bold long-term plan to sell to advisors

IFP Securities’ owner, Bill Hamm, has a long-term plan for the firm and its 279 financial advisors.

Fintech bytes: Vanilla, Wealth.com forge new estate planning partnerships
Fintech bytes: Vanilla, Wealth.com forge new estate planning partnerships

Meanwhile, a Osaic and Envestnet ink a new adaptive wealthtech partnership to better support the firm's 10,000-plus advisors, and RIA-focused VastAdvisor unveils native integrations with leading CRMs.

Fiduciary failure: Ex-advisor who sold practice fined after clients lost millions
Fiduciary failure: Ex-advisor who sold practice fined after clients lost millions

A former Alabama investment advisor and ex-Kestra rep has been permanently barred and penalized after clients he promised to protect got caught in a $2.6 million fraud.

Why the evolution of ETFs is changing the due diligence equation
Why the evolution of ETFs is changing the due diligence equation

As more active strategies get packaged into the ETF wrapper, advisors and investors have to look beyond expense ratios as the benchmark for value.

SPONSORED Are hedge funds the missing ingredient?

Wellington explores how multi strategy hedge funds may enhance diversification

SPONSORED Beyond wealth management: Why the future of advice is becoming more human

As technical expertise becomes increasingly commoditized, advisors who can integrate strategy, relationships, and specialized expertise into a cohesive client experience will define the next era of wealth management