Robinhood Social could be 'blind leading the blind,' Altruist's Jason Wenk warns

Robinhood Social could be 'blind leading the blind,' Altruist's Jason Wenk warns
[from left] Spiegelman Wealth Management CEO Adam Spiegelman, Mitlin Financial founder Lawrence Sprung, Altruist CEO Jason Wenk
Robinhood "financial superapp" includes plans for a new social network that could have additional risks, Altruist CEO Jason Wenk told InvestmentNews, as other RIAs applaud Robinhood's transparent approach to social trading.
SEP 22, 2025

Robinhood’s plan to launch a social media platform is drawing mixed reactions from the financial advisory industry, as it also anticipates the fintech giant’s upcoming referral program to connect RIAs with the company's young investor base. 

Robinhood Social was announced last week at the HOOD Summit in Las Vegas; it will debut in the Robinhood app for select US customers early next year. Users will be able to post their trades to their social feed, discuss investment strategies and market moves, and track stock trades to mimic from billionaires, politicians, and other high-profile figures. To post on the platform, a user’s profile will display their past trades, enter and exit positions, and performance.

“I do like the idea that those who post will need to disclose their holdings in the security they write about, and their position will continue to be tracked over time,” Larry Sprung, founder of the Carson Group-affiliated Mitlin Financial, told InvestmentNews. “This is something that is inherently missing from other platforms that allow influencers to simply talk about securities that, in many instances, they do not and have never owned.”

A Gallup poll published earlier this year found that 42% of American adults under 30 are getting financial advice from social media, prompting concerns of the rise of “finfluencers” producing this content. A real estate Ponzi scheme from social media influencer Tyler Bossetti defrauded investors of more than $20 million, the DOJ ruled in June.

“This feature will further entrench an already-existing problem with the internet — investors taking financial advice from potentially unqualified influencers on YouTube or TikTok or X,” Andrew Herzog, advisor at Texas-based RIA The Watchman Group, said of Robinhood Social.

“I do not take issue with this type of platform, as there are differences between traders and investors,” Sprung said. “The families that work with RIA firms are typically investors, and those that are attracted to Robinhood and a social media platform like this will be traders.”

Financial 'superapp'


Robinhood CEO Vlad Tenev said its new social feature is part of the company’s goal to deliver a “financial superapp” to customers for trading stocks, options, crypto, an alternatives fund for private market investing, and sports betting through prediction markets.

Nearly 27 million investors have Robinhood accounts, spanning $279 billion in total platform assets, per the company’s Q2 2025 financial results.

"Robinhood’s plan to launch a social media platform is fascinating. There’s clearly a demand for community among investors, whether they’re in their 20s or nearing retirement. If it’s structured well, it could be a positive force — almost like a 'WebMD for finance,' where people can compare experiences but also access vetted commentary from real advisors," said Adam Spiegelman, who departed Commonwealth this year to launch his own RIA Spiegelman Wealth Management. But "without that structure, though, it risks becoming an echo chamber for speculation, much like the AMC/GameStop meme-stock craze," he said.

“From a compliance perspective, the conversations are already happening on Reddit, TikTok, and Discord. Hosting them inside Robinhood makes regulators’ jobs harder, but it also creates an opportunity,” said Spiegelman. "FINRA and the SEC could use this as a way to encourage better disclosures, disclaimers, and even channels where advisors can participate responsibly. Personally, I’d be open to contributing in that kind of forum with the right guardrails.”

'Blind leading the blind'


Unlike other popular social platforms such as Reddit where users can discuss their trading, Robinhood is a member of both the SEC and FINRA through its brokerage subsidiary, Robinhood Financial LLC. Jason Wenk, CEO and founder of the RIA custodian platform Altruist, warns that a “blind lead the blind” discourse is likely to come from Robinhood Social. 

“If you build a social network and the primary premise is you can track other people's portfolios and all of their trades, by default what will happen is people will want to sort those by who are producing the best results,” Wenk told InvestmentNews. “And many investors, if they're not guided properly they're going to look at those results over short time periods like, oh my goodness this person's up 80% the last two years and the market's only up 20%, they must have figured it all out.”

Wenk’s Altruist competes alongside legacy firms such as Fidelity and Schwab in the RIA custody market. Robinhood is also preparing to enter this space through its acquisition of custodian TradePMR in February for $300 million.

“Making it easy for people to track short term performance of non-professionals could be highly speculative and very dangerous to follow, and then encouraging them to follow that type of trading is not sound,” Wenk said. “We all know because we have compliance teams, if we advertise performance as an advisor, or mutual fund or whatever it is — you always have to put the big bold disclaimer that past performance is not indicative of future results.”

Robinhood Investor Index tracks the performance of the top-100 owned investments on Robinhood. The published index includes text that reads “past performance does not guarantee future results,” on Robinhood’s website. “They track that index against the NASDAQ 100, which is what the [Robinhood] index most closely replicates. And the average customer is getting roughly one half the return of the index,” said Wenk. “So creating a message board for people to share what they're doing, I think is a pretty good way to let the blind lead the blind.”

Compliance challenges


Earlier this year, the SEC announced that Robinhood agreed to pay a $45 million fine over securities law violations, and FINRA fined the firm $30 million. Regulators have also investigated Robinhood’s in-app prediction markets for wagering on sporting events.

“I think advisors are just so important, we need to have voices of reason to help people make good decisions. Putting sports betting in your trading app, that's not good for humankind,” said Wenk.

“I think [Robinhood is] killer at building stuff. I do wish they would take that killer product ability and focus it on things that we know produce better outcomes for people like reducing costs, trading less frequently, lowering your taxes,” Wenk said.

Latest News

Merrill broker, whose name was in the Epstein files, has left the firm: Reports.
Merrill broker, whose name was in the Epstein files, has left the firm: Reports.

Paul V. Morris worked at multiple firms across Wall Street and most recently in Manhattan for Merrill Lynch.

Andrew Left found guilty of securities fraud scheme
Andrew Left found guilty of securities fraud scheme

Convicted by an LA jury on 13 of 17 counts, the Citron Research founder and activist short seller now is now facing a statutory 25-year federal prison sentence.

Wealthspire's Ground Control targets UK golf market with Arena Wealth deal
Wealthspire's Ground Control targets UK golf market with Arena Wealth deal

The deal marks Ground Control's second UK transaction in under two years as US wealth platforms race to stake out overseas territory.

The most expensive investing mistake has nothing to do with markets
The most expensive investing mistake has nothing to do with markets

Investors' tendency to choose external goalposts can seriously impact their odds of long-term success – and they might not even know it.

DOL’s new 401(k) proposal fraught with challenges for fiduciaries: Lawyer
DOL’s new 401(k) proposal fraught with challenges for fiduciaries: Lawyer

“We fear that it will be ‘open season’ from the plaintiffs’ bar on plan fiduciaries who are early adopters of alternative investments,” said Tim Collins, a partner at Duane Morris.

SPONSORED Estate planning isn't a service add-on. It's your retention strategy.

As $84 trillion prepares to change hands, advisors who treat estate planning as peripheral are quietly building a sieve, not a book.

SPONSORED Why strategy matters more than performance

In volatile markets, the advisors who win aren't the ones with the best calls - they're the ones whose clients stay the course.