Two sides of the same (gold) coin: Bears vs. bulls

Investors seeing the same set of data but making different bets.
APR 15, 2013
The price of gold will continue to drop like a rock. Why? “Because that's all it is — a rock,” said Doug Cote, chief market strategist at ING U.S. Investment Management. Well, technically, gold is a metal. But Mr. Cote's point is clear: Gold's value as a currency or inflation hedge is waning. A recent dip in the price of the precious metal to around $1,578 per ounce represented a 5% drop from the start of the year, which compares with an 8.7% gain last year. While the market remains mixed on the near-term outlook for gold, investors and analysts supporting the price decline are following the logic that the overall economic environment is improving and gold is losing its luster as a defensive play. “The trends have been in place for some time,” Mr. Cote said. “I've been bearish on gold for over a year, because it's a flippin' rock and it's way overpriced.” The flip side of the “flippin' rock” argument is that the good news investors are embracing is flat-out wrong and an allocation to gold still makes sense. “This [price decline] could turn around at any minute and we want to be there for the up moves,” said Joe Foster, manager of the $1.1 billion Van Eck International Investors Gold Fund (INIVX). “Gold thrives on financial risk and we still have so much risk out there in the financial system,” he added. “We could be sitting here in the fourth quarter and looking at higher unemployment and more talk of quantitative easing.” In fact, Thursday's report of higher-than-expected unemployment claims was credited with boosting the price of gold $2.30 in morning trading to more than $1,580 an ounce. Essentially, while part of the market sees an improving U.S. economy, reduced sovereign-debt issues in Europe, an improving domestic housing market and some signs of progress coming out of Washington, investors such as Mr. Foster realize that gold remains highly sensitive to macroeconomic influences. “All the reasons that people think we're returning to normal and don't need gold as a hedge are all the things we're still worried about,” he said. “We still have a high conviction that we're in the midst of an ongoing gold bull market.” To be fair, that is exactly the sort of argument a portfolio manager such as Mr. Foster has to believe, since his fund is mandated by prospectus to have at least 80% of its assets invested in gold or gold-related vehicles. Thus when the price of gold is falling, he tends to load up on bullion because it won't decline as much as gold-mining and producing companies. Then there are advisers such as Roger Pine of Briaud Financial Advisors, who has a 10% allocation to gold and is planning to add more during the price pullback. “We've been in gold in varying degrees since 2003 and we're seeing this pullback as a buying opportunity,” he said. “Gold is more than just an inflation hedge. It's the one currency that can't be manipulated by the central banks.” Mr. Pine said his original and primary focus on gold relates to the emerging middle-class populations in places such as India and China. “We see gold as a way to invest in that new wealth,” he said. The volatility of the precious metal is part of the deal, he added, citing peak-to-trough periods in 2006 and 2008 when gold prices declined by 23% and 30%, respectively. “Absolutely, this pullback is a buying opportunity,” he said. Somewhere between the gold bugs and the gold bears there are also those who recognize gold as a simple hedging tool. “I don't view gold as an investment because it doesn't pay a dividend or interest and, in fact, it cost you money to own it,” said Rex Macey, chief investment officer at Wilmington Trust Investment Advisors. “I think of gold as insurance against the loss of value of paper currency,” he said. “But that's about it; it doesn't usually give you more than that.”

Latest News

Alaris Acquisitions CEO: AI-driven staff reductions could boost RIA valuations
Alaris Acquisitions CEO: AI-driven staff reductions could boost RIA valuations

CEO Allen Darby sees a coming shift in M&A dynamics as AI eliminates clerical roles at RIAs, leaving buyers and sellers to negotiate who benefits from the added margin.

Private equity in 401(k)s is 'inevitable,' says Meketa Capital CEO
Private equity in 401(k)s is 'inevitable,' says Meketa Capital CEO

Michael Bell explains how the PE push in retirement plans will benefit investors, why warnings around risks may be overplayed, and what it will take to get plan fiduciaries comfortable with private investments.

IRA rollovers from DC plans to hit $1.15T by 2030, LIMRA says
IRA rollovers from DC plans to hit $1.15T by 2030, LIMRA says

Research highlights the dominant role of workplace retirement plans and breaks down the major factors dictating workers' IRA rollover decisions.

GReminders unveils autonomous AI assistant for financial advisors
GReminders unveils autonomous AI assistant for financial advisors

The wealth tech firm is rolling out its "Do Anything" assistant as leaders and strategists tout the next evolution of artificial intelligence.

Court strikes down SEC CAT funding plan, puts broker-dealer costs under fire
Court strikes down SEC CAT funding plan, puts broker-dealer costs under fire

Appeals court overturns SEC’s CAT funding plan, broker-dealers face new uncertainty.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.