Former SEC Chair Clayton makes case for democratizing alternative investments

Former SEC Chair Clayton makes case for democratizing alternative investments
Clayton took a swipe at the current leadership of the Securities and Exchange Commission for swinging too far in the wrong direction.
JUN 07, 2023

Former SEC chairman Jay Clayton, who is now working in the private sector and has no interest in returning to government work, believes government regulators could do a much better job serving investors and the broader financial markets.

Speaking Wednesday morning in Orlando, Florida, as part of the BNY Mellon Pershing Insite conference, Clayton drew stark contrasts between the Securities and Exchange Commission under the Biden administration and under the Trump administration.

“I think it’s pretty clear we’re in a very highly business-skeptical and commercial-skeptical regulatory environment,” he said. “Any time you go to extremes, either way, you get more bad than good.”

Clayton, who was SEC chairman from May 2017 through December 2020 and is now the nonexecutive chair at Apollo Global Management, said the regulatory whiplash leaves anyone participating in the financial markets with more questions than answers.

“People don’t know what is really happening, how long it is going to last, and what they should do about it,” he said in reference to what has been described as the most aggressive SEC ever.

On the subject of the democratization of alternative investments, which has been a recent SEC focus, Clayton acknowledged that he might be accused of “talking his book” as the representative of a firm that manages private investments, but said retail class investors are being locked out of the party.

“Capital formation these days largely comes from outside the public markets, yet the investing public is largely held outside those private markets,” he said. “All investors should have access to a portfolio that looks like a well-managed pension fund. With the help of a lot of the people in this room, I think we’re going to be able to do it.”

Lowering the hurdles toward democratization of alternative investments, he explained, requires the participation of the regulators, but also will take additional efforts on the part of investment management firms to create products that are suited for a broader universe of investors.

He took particular issue with the current accreditation rules, which haven’t been changed in 40 years, and don’t jibe with the current reality of individual investors being responsible for their own retirement income.

For example, he pointed out the absurdity of qualified retirement accounts giving retail investors access to highly liquid mutual funds and ETFs but not less liquid investments that would be better suited for long-term investing objectives.

“You’re paying for liquidity that you don’t need and can’t access,” he said. “Pick a target-date fund, for example. Why wouldn’t there be a sliver of privates or alternatives in there? If I’m a 401(k) investor, I should be able to get something that looks like a Calpers portfolio. Why wouldn’t you have a 10% slice of privates in your retirement portfolio when you’re 50 years old?”

Demand for alternative investments not slowing, says Hightower strategist

Latest News

Edward Jones announces C-suite shakeup with eye toward next chapter
Edward Jones announces C-suite shakeup with eye toward next chapter

The leadership changes coming in June, which also include wealth management and digital unit heads, come as the firm pushes to offer more comprehensive services.

Harvard muni bonds a buy amid battle with Trump White House, Barclays says
Harvard muni bonds a buy amid battle with Trump White House, Barclays says

Strategist sees relatively little risk of the university losing its tax-exempt status, which could pose opportunity for investors with a "longer time horizon."

The great wealth transfer demands a wealth management revolution
The great wealth transfer demands a wealth management revolution

As the next generation of investors take their turn, advisors have to strike a fine balance between embracing new technology and building human connections.

Independent Financial Group taps industry veteran Keefe as new president, COO
Independent Financial Group taps industry veteran Keefe as new president, COO

IFG works with 550 producing advisors and generates about $325 million in annual revenue, said Dave Fischer, the company's co-founder and chief marketing officer.

Net Positive Consortium gains momentum with new members, first strategic partner
Net Positive Consortium gains momentum with new members, first strategic partner

Five new RIAs are joining the industry coalition promoting firm-level impact across workforce, client, community and environmental goals.

SPONSORED Compliance in real time: Technology's expanding role in RIA oversight

RIAs face rising regulatory pressure in 2025. Forward-looking firms are responding with embedded technology, not more paperwork.

SPONSORED Advisory firms confront crossroads amid historic wealth transfer

As inheritances are set to reshape client portfolios and next-gen heirs demand digital-first experiences, firms are retooling their wealth tech stacks and succession models in real time.