Wrong birthday info led to $130K in RMD penalties, plaintiffs say

Wrong birthday info led to $130K in RMD penalties, plaintiffs say
A Wells Fargo client who was born in 1939 had his birthdate incorrectly recorded as 2001, according to a lawsuit.
JAN 05, 2024

The beneficiaries of a family trust have sued Wells Fargo over a clerical error made more than 20 years ago that they say has since cost them more than $130,000 in penalties from the IRS.

In 2001, an advisor to the trust established by George Lowe allegedly entered an incorrect birthdate of Jan. 1, 2001, for one of the beneficiaries, who was born in 1939. The error went undetected for years, until a different advisor for the trust told the family that the levels of prior required minimum distributions seemed low.

And indeed they were, according to the lawsuit filed Dec. 21 in U.S. District Court in Louisiana. As of 2021, the trust had distributed about $570,000, though nearly $843,000 should have been distributed, which led to the considerable IRS penalty. Lowe died in 2011, and there are several family member beneficiaries named in the trust.

The former Wells Fargo advisor who worked with the trust, Blake Kymen, died in 2018. Another former Wells Fargo advisor who took over the account afterward, Oscar Hernandez, moved to Morgan Stanley, and the trust client went with him. Neither Kymen's estate nor Hernandez are named as defendants in the suit.

The error was discovered in late 2022, according to the complaint.

As a result, one of the beneficiaries, Jacqueline Lowe, incurred legal fees, was bumped into a higher tax bracket because of higher lump sums distributed recently, and has had her Social Security benefits reduced, the lawsuit states. The plaintiffs allege negligence and breach of fiduciary duty.

News of the lawsuit was reported earlier this week by industry publication Financial Advisor IQ.

Wells Fargo declined to comment about the case.

How to use a holistic approach to reduce financial stress

Latest News

Asset-Map, VastAdvisor launches help solve advisors' growth puzzle
Asset-Map, VastAdvisor launches help solve advisors' growth puzzle

Asset-Map makes a bet on a partner ecosystem while VastAdvisor goes deeper on AI and CRM integration to help advisors grow.

RightCapital claims industry first with AI agent for financial planning
RightCapital claims industry first with AI agent for financial planning

The fintech firm's Iris agent arrives as other financial planning tech providers move quickly to incorporate AI into their workflows.

Advisor moves: LPL lands $500M Tribute Financial team from United Planners
Advisor moves: LPL lands $500M Tribute Financial team from United Planners

Also, a Fidelity veteran goes indie with Osaic OSJ Innovative Financial Group, and Citizens welcomes a sports and entertainment-focused trio previously overseeing $800 million from Morgan Stanley.

Wealth management star Dimple Shah joins Humanity Labs to help drive AI push
Wealth management star Dimple Shah joins Humanity Labs to help drive AI push

Former Osaic executive Shah has joined the self-described AI workforce company as managing director in charge of its engagement efforts with wealth firms.

SEC probes private equity continuation vehicles amid surge in deals
SEC probes private equity continuation vehicles amid surge in deals

The SEC enforcement division is reportedly digging into potential conflicts of interest, valuations, and disclosure in fast-growing fund manager-led transactions.

SPONSORED Who builds the income when the pension disappears?

Dan Biagini of American Equity says the steady decline of pensions, longer lifespans and a reset in interest rates are rewriting how advisors build retirement income

SPONSORED Why direct indexing stopped being optional

Direct indexing is on pace to outgrow ETFs and mutual funds. Northern Trust's Ken Lassner explains why the advisors who get it wish they had started sooner.