2020: The year Wall Street lost the wealth management race

2020: The year Wall Street lost the wealth management race

COVID-19 slowed down but did not halt the flow of advisers fleeing wirehouse firms for the independent channel

2020 was the year that made clear the independent registered investment advisers, and broker-dealers who also work with RIAs, will eclipse the four remaining Wall Street wirehouses in the wealth management and investment advice race.

COVID-19 slowed down but did not halt the flow of advisers fleeing Merrill Lynch, Morgan Stanley, Wells Fargo Advisors and UBS. With many wirehouse advisers not working in the office due to the pandemic, those advisers in some instances had an easier time of leaving because fewer advisers were around to chase after their clients.

First, some numbers. According to a filing in October by Kingswood Acquisition Corp., a new special acquisition company focused on wealth management mergers and acquisitions, wirehouses have been losing wealth management market share to RIAs since the credit crisis over a decade ago.

“Wirehouse asset market share fell from 42.6% to 34.0% between 2007 and 2018 and is expected to fall further to 29.2% by 2023,” according to the filing, which cited industry consultants as the source of the material. “Conversely, RIAs and hybrid RIA firms saw an increase in their collective asset market share from 16.8% to 24.2% between 2007 and 2018 and are expected to have an asset market share of 29.6% by 2023.”

“One of the key factors driving the shift of financial advisors to the RIA channel is the ability to retain a greater share of the economics associated with the wealth management services they provide,” according to the research. Simply put, advisers have the potential to make more money if they leave a wirehouse and move to or launch an RIA.

And 2020 showed the wirehouses are working flatfooted in the RIA market, ceding the fastest growing part of the investment advice industry to the competition.

Meanwhile, independent broker-dealers and RIAs are targeting wirehouse advisers like never before, catering to their needs and business whims. Commonwealth Financial Network, one of the most successful independent broker-dealers, has recently lowered its pricing on separately managed accounts, bringing them in line with the competition to lure advisers. It has boosted its transition bonus for recruits with an eye on wirehouse advisers.

The indies are using the wirehouse playbook against them. For example, LPL Financial in 2018 tapped a wirehouse veteran, Rich Steinmeier, who helped launch the wildly successful Merrill Edge, to take over as head of recruiting. And LPL this year launched a platform for wirehouse advisers and promised to increase those advisers’ payouts.

They both seem to be taking a page from Dynasty Financial Partners, one of the most notable third-party service companies that provide technology and infrastructure so wirehouse advisers can seamlessly resign from a bank on and open a new office in days.

Sure, wirehouses are trying to hang onto those advisers’ assets, but the lower pay and the fight to control the client by pushing banking products on customers, is a true drag for advisers.

What are the wirehouses doing to compete? Only one, Wells Fargo Advisors, has actually opened an RIA custody arm to do so. Others, including Morgan Stanley, have reportedly studied the idea, and Morgan Stanley actually acquired a small RIA custody business when it bought online and discount broker ETrade Financial Corp. So, while it’s in a strong position to enter the RIA custody business, it publicly hasn’t said what it’s going to do.

The problem for Morgan Stanley, as well as the other wirehouses, is that RIA platforms like ETrade Advisor Services are in direct competition for tens of thousands of financial advisers who are employees. Broker-dealers like Morgan Stanley also make huge profits from trading and sales commissions, types of businesses that RIA custodians do not play in.

So, there you have it — the independent broker-dealer and RIA sides of the business know exactly what they will do to lure wirehouse brokers to their side of the street, which pays better and gives advisers the incentive of owning their own business and turning bigger profits.

On the wirehouse side, the big four still have the wealthiest clients and their advisers average $1 million or more in annual revenue, two to three times the average investment adviser rep at many firms. Unlucky for them, their top advisers have fully realized how to transition to another business model, and make more money.

Recent Articles by Author

IBDs saw decent year in 2020 wirehouse recruiting

IBDs saw decent year in 2020 wirehouse recruiting

Independent broker-dealers saw gains in recruiting coveted wirehouse advisers despite the massive disruptions caused by COVID-19. Firms are also building out registered investment advisory platforms to lure advisers.

Broker-dealers brace for cyberthreats

Broker-dealers brace for cyberthreats

2020 was the year that independent broker-dealers needed to rely on technology more than ever, with home-office staff and a large number of advisers working from home or in remote offices. What if criminals breach a broker-dealer's cyber wall?

Wells Fargo reports another sharp annual decline in advisers

Wells Fargo reports another sharp annual decline in advisers

Financial advisers are usually off-limits when it comes to large institutions looking to cut costs and personnel. But Wells Fargo, under CEO Charlie Scharf, has not shied away from laying off advisers or cutting adviser-lead businesses.


Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print