As Stifel fights one giant claim involving star Miami broker, it quietly settles others

As Stifel fights one giant claim involving star Miami broker, it quietly settles others
The competing legal strategies appear contrary to Stifel's public statements about defending its structured notes' tactics.
MAY 23, 2025

Stifel Financial Corp.’s broker-dealer arm is quietly settling a series of customer complaints involving star broker Chuck Roberts while simultaneously working in federal court to overturn the stunning $133 million customer complaint it lost in March. 

According to Roberts’ BrokerCheck profile, Stifel Nicolaus & Co., the broker-dealer arm of the holding company, settled one investor claim related to Roberts in February for $205,000, another in March for $2 million, and one more in April for $16 million.

The products clients purchased included structured notes and hedge funds, according to the BrokerCheck report. Clients' allegations against the firm included breach of fiduciary duty, negligence, and fraud.

Meanwhile, in federal court in Miami on May 16, Stifel Nicolaus filed its motion to vacate the $133 million arbitration award.

In its filing, the firm said the FINRA award, a majority of which consisted of punitive damages and attorneys’ fees, was “a shocking, runaway award in a FINRA arbitration that was infected with fundamental prejudice by a panel member who had already pre-determined that Stifel had acted improperly and lied about her ability to be impartial when she refused to step aside.”

“The result was the largest award in FINRA history in a retail customer arbitration,” according to the filing.

FINRA arbitration panels awarding large amounts of punitive damages is uncommon.

A spokesperson for Stifel declined to comment about any potential settlements with customers.

InvestmentNews reported almost two years ago that Roberts, a veteran financial advisor with Stifel Nicolaus, faced a rash of investor complaints stemming from the sale of potentially volatile structured notes, the performance of which is typically tied to an underlying asset, such as a specific stock or an index like the S&P 500 stock index.

Stifel began losing investor complaints in 2024, as investors won multi-million awards in the securities industry private legal forum, FINRA Dispute Resolution Services. Then, this winter, it lost the giant claim to David Jannetti and family members, who in 2023 sued Stifel Nicolaus.

The competing legal strategies, recently settling investors claims behind closed doors and duking it out in court over the Jannetti decision, appear contrary to Stifel’s public statements about defending Roberts’ structured notes’ strategy. 

Wall Street banks underwrite structured notes, which can be volatile because they're a hybrid of a bond and a derivative. Some notes have principal protection but others don’t, and investors can lose a portion or all their principal based on the terms of the note and market volatility.

In the past, Stifel has said it would move to or attempt to vacate the awards in federal court, with judges in that venue reluctant to overturn private arbitration decisions.

Jeff Erez, a plaintiff’s attorney representing many of the customers suing Stifel, including the Jannetti family, declined to comment about any ongoing or past legal claims.

“Our firm has filed additional cases [involving Roberts] and we believe there are additional investors out there,” Erez said.

Latest News

Social Security trustees see one less year in insolvency countdown, project shortfall to start 2034
Social Security trustees see one less year in insolvency countdown, project shortfall to start 2034

New report shows dimmed outlook for benefits to retirees and disabled Americans, creating further pressure for federal tax hikes or more borrowing.

NY Republican Stefanik presses SEC to probe Harvard bond sale
NY Republican Stefanik presses SEC to probe Harvard bond sale

Open letter to SEC Chair Paul Atkins questions whether the Ivy League university withheld material information prior to its $750 million taxable bond offering.

Ex-LPL leader re-emerges at The Wealth Consulting Group
Ex-LPL leader re-emerges at The Wealth Consulting Group

The Las Vegas-based hybrid RIA overseeing $8.8 billion in assets has named Andy Kalbaugh president to help scale its advisor platform.

Envestnet extends investment offerings with new alts model portfolios
Envestnet extends investment offerings with new alts model portfolios

The wealth tech giant – in collaboration with Fidelity, BlackRock, State Street, and Franklin Templeton – is offering its advisor and wealth firm users more ways to diversify.

Just as wealth industry M&A was picking up, economic uncertainty could kill it again
Just as wealth industry M&A was picking up, economic uncertainty could kill it again

Deal volume increased post-election but now caution has taken over.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.

SPONSORED Beyond the dashboard: Making wealth tech human

How intelliflo aims to solve advisors' top tech headaches—without sacrificing the personal touch clients crave