Is the independent broker-dealer model really 'severely flawed'?

This week, when Ric Edelman revealed that he plans to wind down his independent contractor business, he labeled the model 'severely flawed', and stirred up - not surprisingly - a good deal of conversation across the industry.
APR 16, 2012
This week, when Ric Edelman revealed that he plans to wind down his independent contractor business, he labeled the model 'severely flawed', and stirred up - not surprisingly - a good deal of conversation across the industry. "Everyone will draw their own conclusions, but I consider the independent-broker-dealer channel severely flawed and question the sustainability of many of the players in the space,” Mr. Edelman told InvestmentNews' Bruce Kelly. “The economics are very challenging in today's environment.” But is the business model really flawed? Or is it really just viable for just a small group of firms? A number of IBDs have exited the business since early 2010 (See an updated list here), but some firms are still performing well. INTV explores the issue.

Latest News

Schwab offers $4,800 credit to cover Claude enterprise seat cost for RIAs
Schwab offers $4,800 credit to cover Claude enterprise seat cost for RIAs

Schwab wants RIAs on Claude’s enterprise plan for its security controls, but most of its firms are too small to fill the 20-seat minimum

RIA M&A ties second-best quarter as PE turns to minority stakes
RIA M&A ties second-best quarter as PE turns to minority stakes

Echelon Partners counted 125 wealth management deals in Q3 2026, with the quarter's biggest deal targets by assets selling minority stakes rather than getting swallowed.

Anthropic IPO filing flags legal risks as Claude advisor offering expands
Anthropic IPO filing flags legal risks as Claude advisor offering expands

The AI lab's S-1 details an FTC probe, AI agent liability exposure and models that escaped testing just as it pushes further into advisor tech stacks

Clients are using AI to challenge financial advice, Pacific Life survey finds
Clients are using AI to challenge financial advice, Pacific Life survey finds

Advisors must navigate misinformation and generational expectations as technology reshapes client relationships.

Jailed Florida broker, facing sexual battery charge, ghosts FINRA
Jailed Florida broker, facing sexual battery charge, ghosts FINRA

The regulator has been trying to reach imprisoned advisor Jason Foley.

SPONSORED Built on insurance experience to deliver on long-term promises

Knighthead Life entered the market with a competitive MYGA. A strong launch earned advisor confidence and paved the way for FIAs.

SPONSORED In the Age of AI, Trust Becomes the Advisor's Greatest Asset

As AI makes financial information more accessible than ever, Lana Hock explains why human judgment, trust, and empathy remain the qualities clients value most in a financial advisor