Stifel Financial Corp.’s broker-dealer unit has seen yet another unfavorable outcome in an industry dispute, and on Friday a three-person arbitration panel ruled Stifel Nicolaus & Co. Inc. pay $7 million in legal costs of advisors who left the firm in 2023 and then were sued by the firm.
It’s the latest significant legal dispute in which Stifel has not prevailed in arbitration under the aegis of Finra Dispute Resolution Services. Just last week, a Finra arbitration panel stunned the financial advice industry and awarded clients of Stifel $132.5 million in damages and legal fees in a dispute centered on a star broker in Miami, Chuck Roberts.
One senior industry executive noted that Stifel may be facing a run of ill luck over such legal claims. “These arbitration awards can go in cycles,” said the executive, who spoke confidentially to InvestmentNews.
A spokesperson for Stifel on Monday did not return a call seeking comment.
This most recent dispute centered on a group of Stifel financial advisors who left the firm two years ago to a recently launched registered investment advisor, Sapient Capital, according to the award. The hearing site was Indianapolis.
Sapient Capital opened in 2023 and has $11.4 billion in total assets. Stifel’s complaint targeted James Knall, who had worked at Stifel from 2005 to March 2023, and five other ex-Stifel advisors who are now registered with the Sapient RIA.
Knall is partner and managing director at Sapient Capital, according to the firm’s Form ADV.
In its complaint, Stifel alleged the advisors with raiding, conspiracy, misappropriation of confidential information and trade secrets, breach of the Protocol for Broker Recruiting, and other charges, according to the Finra panel’s award.
The complaint related to Stifel’s allegation that the advisors spent months planning and orchestrating a raid on one of Stifel’s branch offices with the intent to move all of Stifel’s client accounts serviced by that office to their newly formed registered investment advisor, Sapient Capital, according to the award. Stifel was seeking at least $50 million in compensatory damages.
The former Stifel advisors denied those allegations and then filed a counterclaim against Stifel.
Stifel was liable for and shall pay Knall and three other advisors $7 million in attorneys’ fees and is also liable and pay Lee Equity Partners, who was not named in the matter, $121,000 for discovery costs. Two other advisors had previously agreed to settlements of the dispute, according to the award.
Lee Equity is a private equity manager and Sapient Capital is one of the companies the manager has invested in, according to its website.
A $141M judgment and a federal asset freeze collide over one shrinking pool
The firm's CFO and EVP of Wealth Management Solutions are the latest executives to exit the broker-dealer.
Clients are saying they would consider switching advisors if another professional offered estate planning services, according to a new Trust & Will survey.
CEO Laurel Taylor says the fintech's composable AI stack helps workers optimize dollars across Trump Accounts, 529s, 401(k)s, and other employee benefits.
The bank has swiped three private banking veterans from BNY as the city climbs the ranks of America's fastest-growing wealth hubs.
Dan Biagini of American Equity says the steady decline of pensions, longer lifespans and a reset in interest rates are rewriting how advisors build retirement income
Direct indexing is on pace to outgrow ETFs and mutual funds. Northern Trust's Ken Lassner explains why the advisors who get it wish they had started sooner.
