Which is worse, accumulating more debt or not saving enough?

Which is worse, accumulating more debt or not saving enough?
Survey reveals Americans’ top financial regrets.
AUG 29, 2024

Taking on too much debt is a bad financial decision, but so is not saving enough for retirement or emergencies. But which is worse?

According to Americans taking part in a new survey, not putting enough money away for later years or a rainy day is likely to be a bigger financial regret (43%) than building up their debt burden (22%).

The Bankrate.com report found that more than three quarters of respondents have a financial regret with the top one being not saving enough for retirement (22%) followed by not saving enough for emergencies (18%).

Taking on too much credit card debt (14%) or student loan debt (5%), not saving enough for their child(ren)’s education (4%) and buying more house than they can afford (2%) were also among the most commonly cited financial regrets.

Four in ten respondents (40%) have made no progress in the past 12 months on tackling their financial regrets, but slightly more (44%) said they have made progress. For those that have not, inflation is a key reason followed by their employment situation.

The firm’s financial regrets survey has been running for seven years and not saving enough for retirement has been the top one six times.

“Saving is a lot less painful than dealing with the debt that results when you don’t have it,” says Bankrate Chief Financial Analyst Greg McBride, CFA. “Paying down debt means doing without, cutting spending, or working more. Saving for retirement and emergencies can be automated through payroll deduction, direct deposit, and automatic transfers. Start modestly and after a couple of pay periods you won’t miss what you don’t see.”

Latest News

Merrill lands four advisor teams as May recruiting data shows firm's two-way churn
Merrill lands four advisor teams as May recruiting data shows firm's two-way churn

Merrill's latest hires span Colorado to Louisiana, even as industry-wide recruiting data suggests the firm is losing almost as many advisors as it gains.

Fund manager sues Kandeo, alleges $100 million FinSocial loss
Fund manager sues Kandeo, alleges $100 million FinSocial loss

The $36 million buy allegedly hid inflated books and a $50 million diversion.

Advisor gets $200,000 from Ameriprise in 'emotional distress' lawsuit
Advisor gets $200,000 from Ameriprise in 'emotional distress' lawsuit

“An award citing emotional distress is very unusual,” an industry executive said.

Workplace financial education linked to stronger financial habits, but participation remains low
Workplace financial education linked to stronger financial habits, but participation remains low

New EBRI research found workers who participated in employer financial education reported higher confidence, literacy and financial satisfaction.

The rise of the super advisor: How AI is redefining competitive advantage in wealth management
The rise of the super advisor: How AI is redefining competitive advantage in wealth management

Beyond operational excellence, the winning advisors of the future are the ones who can reach across multiple disciplines without discarding specialist skills.

SPONSORED Direct indexing webinar targets tax-loss harvesting amid market swings

Northern Trust’s Ken Lassner shows advisors how to convert volatility into after-tax portfolio gains

SPONSORED Who builds the income when the pension disappears?

Dan Biagini of American Equity says the steady decline of pensions, longer lifespans and a reset in interest rates are rewriting how advisors build retirement income