J.P. Morgan loses $1.4 million defamation case to adviser

J.P. Morgan loses $1.4 million defamation case to adviser
The former adviser alleged that J.P. Morgan Securities defamed him on the Form U5 it filed when he was discharged in 2017.
FEB 11, 2022

A Finra arbitration panel ordered J.P. Morgan Securities to pay $1.4 million in damages to a former financial adviser who sued the firm claiming it had dirtied up his employment history when he was "discharged," meaning fired, almost five years ago.

According to the arbitration award by the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc. panel, the adviser, Dustin B. Luckett, alleged in his arbitration claim that the employment form, called a Form U5, that J.P. Morgan filed was defamatory.

Luckett asserted the following, according to the award: invasion of privacy, tortious interference with prospective business expectancies and other claims after he stopped working at J.P. Morgan Securities in June 2017.

Firms are required to file registration records with regulators when an adviser stops work. It's widely believed by many in the industry that firms can take advantage of the U5 system to harm advisers' reputations.

According to Luckett's BrokerCheck profile, he was fired after asking a co-worker to notarize a document a client had signed without the client being present. J.P. Morgan Securities also claimed Luckett "engaged in conduct it deemed inconsistent with its anti-retaliation policies."

The arbitration hearing took place in Louisville, Kentucky.

A spokesperson for JPMorgan Chase declined to comment on the matter.

"Luckett is very pleased with the award," said his attorney, Michael A. Valenti. "A big part of that is to clear his name, and the arbitration panel's recommendation of full expungement with favorable language is what he’s been fighting for for years."

The Finra arbitration panel gave no reasoning for its decision, which was dated Feb. 4. Luckett worked at Chase Investment Services Corp. and J.P. Morgan Securities from 2011 to 2017. The panel also recommended that the company expunge or change the language on his employment history to reflect that the reasoning wasn't related to investments but rather a dispute over the clerical process of notarizing.

"I believe all assertions placed on my Form U5 were purposely put there in order to hamper my future employment prospects and coerce existing client to remain" with JPMorgan Chase, Luckett wrote on his BrokerCheck report in response to the firm.

Luckett, who's no longer registered with a brokerage firm, originally asked for more than $4.2 million in damages, according to the award. Valenti, his attorney, said he was working at a bank.

Latest News

Edward Jones facing more race bias claims in new lawsuit
Edward Jones facing more race bias claims in new lawsuit

A private partnership, Edward Jones is a giant in the retail brokerage industry with more than 20,000 financial advisors.

Advisor moves: LPL recruitment momentum continues with $815M Northwestern Mutual team
Advisor moves: LPL recruitment momentum continues with $815M Northwestern Mutual team

Meanwhile, Raymond James and Tritonpoint Partners separately welcomed father-son teams, including a breakaway from UBS in Missouri.

SEC chief Atkins signals caution on prediction market ETFs amid broader rethink of novel fund structures
SEC chief Atkins signals caution on prediction market ETFs amid broader rethink of novel fund structures

Paul Atkins has asked staff to solicit public comment on novel ETFs, pausing the clock on as many as 24 filings linked to the booming event contracts market.

Private capital's $1 trillion bet on the American retirement account
Private capital's $1 trillion bet on the American retirement account

From 401(k)s to retail funds, Deloitte sees private equity and credit crossing into mainstream investing on two fronts at once.

Advisor moves: Wells Fargo Advisors pulls in $9.6b in fresh talent during first half of May
Advisor moves: Wells Fargo Advisors pulls in $9.6b in fresh talent during first half of May

Big-name defections from Morgan Stanley, UBS, and Merrill Lynch headline a busy two weeks of recruiting for the wirehouse.

SPONSORED Are hedge funds the missing ingredient?

Wellington explores how multi strategy hedge funds may enhance diversification

SPONSORED Beyond wealth management: Why the future of advice is becoming more human

As technical expertise becomes increasingly commoditized, advisors who can integrate strategy, relationships, and specialized expertise into a cohesive client experience will define the next era of wealth management