Suitability rule seen unsuitable for 'hold' orders

JUL 15, 2012
Broker-dealers are still feeling their way on how to comply with at least one aspect of the new Finra suitability requirements: how to track brokers' recommendations to hold on to a specific security. Firms are confounded by this part of the rule because their systems track only “sell” and “buy” orders. “With the hold, it's an absence of a transaction. There are no checks and no applications being submitted, so how do you document it?” asked Mark Quinn, chief risk officer at First Allied Securities Inc. “Finra believes it is important that a broker's explicit recommendation to hold a security be suitable for the customer,” said Finra spokeswoman Michelle Ong. “With that said, Finra appreciates that firms have been working hard to develop approaches to supervising such recommendations.” Firms are implementing different ways to document situations of this type. Some, for example, are using “hold” tickets to reflect the rep's recommendation, while others are simply asking reps to document when a client is told to hold on to a security. First Allied uses a “hold blotter” to record particular transaction details, as well as additional documentation for certain risky assets. Investments such as options and structured products warrant that extra layer of detail, Mr. Quinn said. John Hancock Financial Network has added a hold check-off on tickets in the event that a broker thinks that he or she made a recommendation, according to Thomas Horack, chief compliance officer. [email protected] Twitter: @darla_mercado

Latest News

Merit Financial snaps up $900M Bridgeway Group in California push
Merit Financial snaps up $900M Bridgeway Group in California push

The Atlanta-based RIA has now completed nine acquisitions in 2026, with six of those coming from Commonwealth Financial Network's former advisor base.

Generational wealth strategies are shifting as families and business owners eye Trump Accounts
Generational wealth strategies are shifting as families and business owners eye Trump Accounts

Half of small business owners want their company's success to fund generational wealth, says Guardian Life research.

Workers delaying retirement as economic anxiety grips employers
Workers delaying retirement as economic anxiety grips employers

New Principal Financial data reveals 69% of US employers say staff are postponing retirement, with inflation cited as the primary driver amid rising AI optimism.

Is Wall Street's AI risk analysis right for RIA portfolios?
Is Wall Street's AI risk analysis right for RIA portfolios?

Anthropic's Millennium partnership moves AI from reactive tool to proactive risk monitor — but other wealth tech leaders question its fit for RIA practices.

AI is resetting trust in wealth services, says Advisor360's new CEO
AI is resetting trust in wealth services, says Advisor360's new CEO

Milind Mehere offers perspective on why ambient AI, not smarter models, will define the next decade of wealth tech.

SPONSORED Direct indexing webinar targets tax-loss harvesting amid market swings

Northern Trust’s Ken Lassner shows advisors how to convert volatility into after-tax portfolio gains

SPONSORED Who builds the income when the pension disappears?

Dan Biagini of American Equity says the steady decline of pensions, longer lifespans and a reset in interest rates are rewriting how advisors build retirement income