Diverse voices drive employees' engagement with financial benefits – and beyond

Diverse voices drive employees' engagement with financial benefits – and beyond
People are more likely to listen to messages delivered by those who appear to share their identities
OCT 11, 2022

Working Americans expect to see people like themselves in employer communications about retirement planning – and that sets a precedent for communications into and through retirement, according to new research from Edelman Financial Engines.

Women, people of color and people with lower incomes are much less likely to see themselves reflected in corporate communications about financial wellness benefits, and that perception correlates with lower usage of those benefits, the study found. Less than half - 46% - of the employees who felt that they were only occasionally represented ended up using the offered financial wellness benefits. But for employees who did feel consistently represented, 74% used the offered financial wellness benefits.

46%) of employees who felt they were being represented only "occasionally or less" admitted to using their company's financial wellness benefits. Alternatively, nearly three-quarters (74%) who "always or often" felt represented in communications used these same benefits.

And, women often perceived that they were not the target audience, with 68% of the study respondents indicating that the messaging did not include them, compared to 58% of men surveyed.

“The more that you are representing and communicating and personalizing information to the individual, the more it resonates and the more it makes an impact,” said Kelly O’Donnell, EVP and head of workplace for Edelman Financial Engines. Diversity-infused communications, she added, is “an untapped opportunity for employers and advisers to think about the backgrounds and life experiences of … investors and clients.”

Employee engagement with important information about financial benefits is hardly academic: employers’ investment in staff financial well-being fails if people don’t connect with the information.

This year’s MetLife Employee Benefit Trends report found that only 54% of employees think that benefits communication “is relevant to them,” and that’s in a context of employers pressing in to integrate financial, mental and physical health with workplace benefits and culture.

The Edelman data indicates that employees both need to hear the message from people whose identities are similar to theirs, and need to absorb a deeper connection through those stories, said O’Donnell.  And diversity reflects race and gender, but also family makeup, gender identity, and other forms of diversity, she added.

“The more you are representing and communicating and personalizing information to the individual, the more it resonates and the more it makes an impact,” she said.

That dynamic carries forward as employees open relationships with advisors, most often in the retirement transition, O’Donnell said. The Edelman Financial Engines study found that 82% of respondents prefer to work with an adviser who has a similar background or family situation, echoing the results of a study released in April by Ariel-Schwab.

That’s where corporate communications tees up new clients’ expectations for communications with their advisers, she said, and where advisers have the chance to understand elements of heritage and life experience that shape those new clients’ approaches to financial management and retirement life.

Advisers can take cues from employee benefit communications that shape new clients’ financial perspectives, said John Jurik, retirement practice leader at Arthur J. Gallagher & Co., an insurance brokerage, risk management and consulting services firm.

“For a lot of people, the corporate communication is all they’ve known,” Jurik said. “You have to meet  people where they are.”

Employees increasingly interact with benefits through a range of channels, especially digital, that establish the tone, tenor and technical terms of retirement planning.  “Find a way to engage with those employees along their financial journey. Work with them during their working career, maybe some financial coaching, and then when they do transition to retirement, you’ve got the relationship,” recommended Jurik.

“It’s an opportunity for the adviser to say, ‘tell me how your parents thought about money,’” said O’Donnell. “It’s about deepening beyond gender and racial background, or any type of identity, to really have empathy and understand where this person is coming from. “

Latest News

A 'just right' moment for munis
A 'just right' moment for munis

After a two-year period of inversion, the muni yield curve is back in a more natural position – and poised to create opportunities for long-term investors.

Advisor moves: UBS exodus continues as Merrill makes additions in California, Texas
Advisor moves: UBS exodus continues as Merrill makes additions in California, Texas

Meanwhile, an experienced Connecticut advisor has cut ties with Edelman Financial Engines, and Raymond James' independent division welcomes a Washington-based duo.

RIA giant Mercer matches 2024 deal count, lays groundwork for Idaho expansion
RIA giant Mercer matches 2024 deal count, lays groundwork for Idaho expansion

Oregon-based Eagle Wealth Management and Idaho-based West Oak Capital give Mercer 11 acquisitions in 2025, matching last year's total. “We think there's a great opportunity in the Pacific Northwest,” Mercer's Martine Lellis told InvestmentNews.

Osaic ponies up $9.8M to settle clients’ lawsuit involving real estate, alternatives
Osaic ponies up $9.8M to settle clients’ lawsuit involving real estate, alternatives

Osaic has now paid $17.2 million to settle claims involving former clients of Jim Walesa.

RIA moves: CW Advisors scores a double in Pennsylvania, Apella Wealth makes Chicago debut
RIA moves: CW Advisors scores a double in Pennsylvania, Apella Wealth makes Chicago debut

Osaic-owned CW Advisors has added more than $500 million to reach $14.5 billion in AUM, while Apella's latest deal brings more than $1 billion in new client assets.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.