Subscribe

STATS: GUESS WHO’S IN THE VANGUARD OF LOW-COST STOCK FUNDS?

Agressive Growth lowest cost Expense 1-YEAR Rank FUND Ratio Return 1 Vanguard Horizon Aggressive Growth 0.38…

Agressive Growth

lowest cost

Expense 1-YEAR

Rank FUND Ratio Return

1 Vanguard Horizon Aggressive Growth 0.38 15.88%

2 USAA Aggressive Growth 0.74 3.75%

3 Putnam Voyager Y 0.77 20.75%

4 Value Line Leveraged Growth 0.86 19.27%

5 Arch Small Cap Equity Trust 0.88 13.64%

6 Markman Aggressive Allocation 0.95 14.75%

7 State Street Research Capital S 0.96 -1.51%

8 Dreyfus Premier Aggressive Growth R 0.98 -19.21%

9 Morgan Stanley Inst’l Aggressive Equity A 1.00 30.13%

10 RBB Ni Growth 1.00 9.95%

highest cost

Expense 1-YEAR

Rank FUND Ratio Return

1 American Heritage 5.42 16.44%

2 Stonebridge Aggressive Growth 2.90 -5.12%

3 Style Select Aggressive Growth B 2.55 12.92%

4 Delaware Group Aggressive Growth B 2.50 35.11%

5 Delaware Group Aggressive Growth C 2.50 35.83%

6 Kemper Aggressive Growth B 2.39 24.15%

7 Morgan Stanley Aggressive Equity C 2.32 27.82%

8 Morgan Stanley Aggressive Equity B 2.32 27.86%

9 Security Ultra B 2.31 7.26%

10 John Hancock Special Opportunities B 2.29 -0.31%

AVERAGE 1.60 11.44%

Vanguard Group, known for thriftiness, placed at least one fund in the top 10 of each style and leads in two of them.

EQUITY INCOME

lowest cost

Expense 1-YEAR

Rank FUND Ratio Return

1 Vanguard Preferred Stock 0.39 14.41%

2 Vanguard Equity Income 0.45 26.50%

3 Lindner Dividend Inv 0.60 8.96%

4 Dreyfus Lifetime Income Rest 0.60 11.71%

5 Income Fund of America 0.61 19.35%

6 Fidelity Equity Income-I 0.66 24.69%

7 Fidelity Puritan 0.66 19.34%

8 USAA Income 0.68 21.61%

9 Delaware Group Decatur Income Inst’l 0.69 24.94%

10 Capital Income Builder 0.71 21.29%

highest cost

Expense 1-YEAR

Rank FUND Ratio Return

1 Style Select Value B 2.
55 20.71%

2 Phoenix-Engemann Value 25 C 2.50 15.00%

3 Phoenix-Engemann Value 25 B 2.50 15.00%

4 Parkstone Equity Income C 2.35 18.15%

5 Parkstone Equity Income B 2.35 18.22%

6 Evergreen Income and Growth B 2.25 20.37%

7 Evergreen Income and Growth C 2.25 20.42%

8 US Income 2.18 20.11%

9 MFS Equity Income C 2.15 27.92%

10 MFS Equity Income B 2.15 27.92%

AVERAGE 1.35 21.38%

The second-thriftiest fund in this sector returned 12 percentage points better than top-ranked Vanguard Preferred.

global equity

lowest cost

Expense 1-Year

Rank FUND Ratio Return

1 Maxim Contrarian 0.25 -10.28%

2 Acorn 0.57 18.60%

3 New Perspective 0.79 15.31%

4 USAA Growth and Income 0.83 19.86%

5 Standish International Equity 0.85 5.85%

6 Vanguard Horizon Global Equity 0.85 7.64%

7 Dreyfus Premier Int’l Growth R 0.87 15.91%

8 Templeton Growth Adv 0.87 13.92%

9 Sierra Trust Capital Growth Portfolio A 0.87 13.92%

10 Janus Worldwide Fund 0.90 10.63%

highest cost

Expense 1-YEAR

Rank FUND Ratio Return

1 Alliance Global Small Cap C 3.10 7.72%

2 Security Equity Fund-Global B 3.00 4.80%

3 Eaton Vance Info Age B 2.96 16.14%

4 Eaton Vance Info Age C 2.88 15.24%

5 Eaton Vance Info Age A 2.87 16.54%

6 GT Global Financial Services B 2.82 21.37%

7 ESC Strategic-Global Equity D 2.78 4.42%

8 Evergreen Global Leaders C 2.75 13.91%

9 Evergreen Global Leaders B 2.75 13.98%

10 Alliance Global Small Cap B 3.11 7.73%

AVERAGE 1.86 10.47%

No. 7 GT Global’s expense ratio was almost a full point above average, but its returns more than doubled the mean.

domestic growth

lowest cost

Expense 1-YEAR

Rank FUND Ratio Return

1 Glenmede Equity 0.13 24.57%

2 State Farm Growth 0.13 19.96%

3 IMS Capital Value
0.16 1.60%

4 Vanguard Tax Managed-Cap Appreciation 0.20 21.08%

5 Vanguard Index Growth Portfolio 0.20 30.60%

6 Vanguard Index Extended Market 0.25 20.69%

7 Vanguard Index Total Stock Market 0.25 24.70%

8 Nations LifeGoal Growth A 0.25 10.84%

9 Firstar Equity Index Inst’l 0.36 26.21%

10 ATT Vision U.S. equity Portfolio 0.38 21.30%

highest cost

Expense 1-YEAR

Rank FUND Ratio Return

1 GAMerica Capital A 4.79 36.99%

2 Eaton Vance Growth C 3.52 18.60%

3 Prudential Distressed Sectors C 3.51 31.77%

4 Prudential Distressed Sectors B 3.51 31.77%

5 Eaton Vance Special Equity C 3.51 8.16%

6 Eaton Vance Special Equity B 3.41 8.58%

7 American Heritage Growth 2.81 -9.00%

8 Prudential Distressed Sectors A 2.76 32.63%

9 FMI Focus 2.75 66.87%

10 Kemper Dreman Contrarian C 2.73 21.14%

AVERAGE 1.77 22.60%

Ninth most expensive FMI Focus aimed at return. It gained nearly three times as much as the average growth fund.

growth & INCOME

lowest cost

Expense 1-YEAR

Rank FUND Ratio Return

1 Strategist Equity 0.08 19.30%

2 ASM Index 30 0.18 17.94%

3 Vanguard Index Value Portfolio 0.20 22.39%

4 Vanguard Tax-Managed G&I 0.20 26.88%

5 Nations LifeGoal Inc & Growth Pr A 0.25 8.60%

6 Transamerica Premier Index 0.25 25.38%

7 Vanguard Windsor I 0.31 14.78%

8 Vanguard G&I Port 0.38 28.22%

9 Vista G&I I 0.38 22.33%

10 Vanguard Windsor II 0.39 24.85%

highest cost

Expense 1-YEAR

Rank FUND Ratio Return

1 Fortis G&I H 3.08 18.48%

2 Fortis G&I B 3.08 18.39%

3 Fortis GG&I C 3.08 18.48%

4 Oppenheimer/Quest G&I Val C 2.88 24.91%

5 Oppenheimer/Quest G&I Val B 2.59 24.86%

6 Calamos G&I C 2.50 19.90%

7 UAM IRC Enhanced Index Portfolio 2.50 20.42%

8 Templeton Ame
rican Trust II 2.40 15.77%

9 Fortis G&I A 2.33 19.46%

10 Prudential Jennison G&I C 2.32 17.66%

AVERAGE 1.31 21.10%

Strategist’s strategy wasn’t all that successful. The expense ratio was certainly low, but the return was below average.

SMALL-CAP equity

lowest cost

Expense 1-YEAR

Rank FUND Ratio Return

1 Glenmede Small Cap Adv 0.14 22.73%

2 Vanguard Index Small Cap 0.25 19.50%

3 Benchmark Small Company Index A 0.32 18.85%

4 BT Advisor Small Cap Index Inst’l 0.45 17.04%

5 BT Inst’l Small Cap Index 0.45 18.06%

6 Schwab Small Cap Index Inv 0.49 19.42%

7 California Invest Trust S&P Small Cap Index 0.61 18.40%

8 Vanguard Explorer Fund 0.63 10.32%

9 MassMutual Inst’l Small Cap S 0.63 32.33%

10 Northern Small Cap Fund 0.65 23.83%

highest cost

Expense 1-YEAR

Rank FUND Ratio Return

1 PaineWebber Small Cap C 2.77 21.30%

2 PaineWebber Small Cap B 2.75 21.38%

3 Delaware Group Small Cap Value C 2.70 25.15%

4 Delaware Group Small Cap Value B 2.70 25.08%

5 GT Global America Small Cap Growth B 2.65 14.06%

6 Alliance Quasar B 2.62 11.54%

7 Alliance Qu

Learn more about reprints and licensing for this article.

Recent Articles by Author

Trump wrong to challenge workplace savings plans

Programs that enhance retirement saving should be encouraged, not assailed.

Women in investing

How firms can tackle the challenges that perpetuate the gender gap in investment roles.

Privacy Policy

Investmentnews.com and InvestmentNews and the associated newsletters, news alerts, data centers, research reports, and other features are products…

Letters to the Editor

“The trend in managing an advisory practice is all about collaboration … with peers, home office associates, [centers…

People

Stifel Financial Corp. of St. Louis has hired William J. Drake, 55, as senior vice president of investments…

X

Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print